Matrix
How China and Asia
Social changes
Alternative Shanghai
How China and Asia
Social changes
Alternative Shanghai

Benoit Vermander
May 28, 2007
Last Updated on Thu, 05 May 2011 10:57
Shanghai is the city of money, of power, of architectural progress… Shanghai is the city of the future… Shanghai is the city where the world is flocking to: Chinese from the hinterland, Taiwanese in search of a larger field of action, multinational companies, artists, adventurers and bankers… Shanghai is also the city where the next International Fair will take place, in 2010, and it ambitions to become then the point around which the entire world will revolve. Where and when is Shanghai’s rise going to stop?
At the same time, Shanghai is often presented as a soulless city: power and money do not harmonize easily with altruism and spiritual quest. The rise of Shanghai profits mostly those who focus on accumulating more wealth and more influence. It does not look like a place for poets or mystics. It is the kingdom of greed, opportunism and working frenzy. Watching the Shanghai of today, the opening line of “A Take of two Cities” comes again to mind” “It was the best of times, it was the worst of times…” Booming Shanghai might be slowly devouring the flesh and soul of its own children.
However, there is another Shanghai, a kindler and gentler city. Since its start, eRenlai nurtures friendship with a group of people who strive to make Shanghai a different place, where people care for their neighbors, where the rights of minorities are recognized, where the weakest are taken into full consideration, where the cultural resources brought by different groups of people are respected and cherished. The initiators of such a movement are Shanghai people themselves. They are helped in many ways by people from outside, who found in Shanghai what they were not initially looking for.
Taiwanese are especially numerous in Shanghai and its surroundings. Most of them deploy there their professional talents, and are making good money out of it. Often, they complain about Shanghai ’ recklessness – while contributing to it. Are they truly looking for the real soul of the city? Are they bringing an example of openness and generosity that would help Chinese civil society to mature and pacify? Are they taking initiatives that contribute to peace and solidarity? Are they just making use of Shanghai or do they contribute to its human development? Some of them may do so. Most of them need to be encouraged to look differently at Shanghai - and to act differently as well.
Our ultimate concern is of course about China’s civil society and its future. People and groups who contribute to accrued solidarity and diversity deserve to be better known, encouraged and empowered. Beyond political and cultural issues, the human quality deployed by citizens and associations is what will make China a better place to live, and a more friendly partner for the rest of Asia and the world. There are reasons for hope, but they are not always obvious. We have to look at China with different eyes. Alternative Shanghai is a good place to start with.
At the same time, Shanghai is often presented as a soulless city: power and money do not harmonize easily with altruism and spiritual quest. The rise of Shanghai profits mostly those who focus on accumulating more wealth and more influence. It does not look like a place for poets or mystics. It is the kingdom of greed, opportunism and working frenzy. Watching the Shanghai of today, the opening line of “A Take of two Cities” comes again to mind” “It was the best of times, it was the worst of times…” Booming Shanghai might be slowly devouring the flesh and soul of its own children.
However, there is another Shanghai, a kindler and gentler city. Since its start, eRenlai nurtures friendship with a group of people who strive to make Shanghai a different place, where people care for their neighbors, where the rights of minorities are recognized, where the weakest are taken into full consideration, where the cultural resources brought by different groups of people are respected and cherished. The initiators of such a movement are Shanghai people themselves. They are helped in many ways by people from outside, who found in Shanghai what they were not initially looking for.
Taiwanese are especially numerous in Shanghai and its surroundings. Most of them deploy there their professional talents, and are making good money out of it. Often, they complain about Shanghai ’ recklessness – while contributing to it. Are they truly looking for the real soul of the city? Are they bringing an example of openness and generosity that would help Chinese civil society to mature and pacify? Are they taking initiatives that contribute to peace and solidarity? Are they just making use of Shanghai or do they contribute to its human development? Some of them may do so. Most of them need to be encouraged to look differently at Shanghai - and to act differently as well.
Our ultimate concern is of course about China’s civil society and its future. People and groups who contribute to accrued solidarity and diversity deserve to be better known, encouraged and empowered. Beyond political and cultural issues, the human quality deployed by citizens and associations is what will make China a better place to live, and a more friendly partner for the rest of Asia and the world. There are reasons for hope, but they are not always obvious. We have to look at China with different eyes. Alternative Shanghai is a good place to start with.
| < Prev | Next > |
|---|

| Written by : Benoit Vermander Send a message to Benoit Vermander |
Other articles by this author
- The extraordinary challenge of living an ordinary life (28 May 2013)
- Religious Colonialism: Cultural Loss in the Solomon Islands (26 April 2013)
- A Vibrant Culture with an Ugly Facade: Honiara and the Pacific Art Festival (26 April 2013)
- Swept away from Sinology by the Allure of Taiwan's Pacific coast (26 April 2013)
- Preaching Tenderness (20 March 2013)
- The Width and Depth of the Ocean within Me: In Memory of Yves Raguin (09 January 2013)
- Suffering at work: a new pandemic (08 January 2013)
- Long Live Crisis! (12 December 2012)
- This little boat that belongs to you and us (26 October 2012)
- Breathing Poetry (14 August 2012)
- The Oceanic Feeling (28 March 2012)
- China's Challenges in the Year of the Dragon (17 February 2012)
- Yi Migrant Workers in Chengdu (27 December 2011)
- Romance of the Three Kingdoms: The Sequel (07 July 2011)
- “Surviving” is not good enough (20 June 2011)
- Moral development is a life-long process (31 May 2011)
- Religions as languages (26 February 2010)
- Forgiveness by ritual (14 January 2010)
- Taoism as a Spiritual Path (31 December 2009)
- Paris of the Orient (31 December 2009)
This month's Renlai
Help us!
Help us keep the content of eRenlai free: take five minutes to make a donation
Your Space
Also read...
- Networks for Mutual Help and Civil Society: from Shanghai to Yunnan
- A New Perspective on the Opening and Development of West China
- Remembering Tushanwan
- Dreaming Taiwan
- Chinese music goes to the sea
- A Museum for Tushanwan
- The new frontier in abolishing the death penalty
- Falun Gong protests in Taipei: An interpretive slideshow
- Europe-China Cooperation in the Digital Era by R. Prodi
- An Expo-lent Australian Adventure
Latest Comments...
A Tale of Three Lands
When reading the sto...
29.04.13 14:01
By Cerise Phiv
A Tale of Three Lands
Did such a story rea...
27.04.13 23:38
By Jin Lu
A Tale of Three Lands
What a beautiful and...
26.04.13 13:09
By Daniel Pagan Murphy
Recent Articles
- A Centre for the Middle Country
- No Nukes = No Future?
- Remembering the 309 Anti-nuclear Protest
- Alternative Protest in Japan: Two Years After Fukushima
- History of the Taiwanese Anti-nuclear Movement
- Recapturing Memories: Social Protests as a Way for Taiwanese Youth to Reconnect with the Past
- The Demonstrative Power of the Carnival: Fun as a Form of Protest
- Art and Social Activism: Mutually Beneficial?
- The Taiwanese Experience: Adjusting to life on the other side of the world
- The extraordinary challenge of living an ordinary life
eRenlai Newsletter
eRenlai provides a monthly newsletter that introduces you to the Focus and other articles.
Who's Online
We have 533 guests and 1 member online
Spiritual Computing
Global Challenges in Local Contexts
How China and Asia Reinvent Themselves
Asian Cultures on the move...
Building Peace in Asia 


